WebNatasha Trethewey Liturgy: A Meditation on the Mississippi Gulf Coast Where you came from is gone. In this book, Natasha Tretheweys poems tell the story of the Louisiana Native Guards. Analyzes how marlow seeks shade from the daytime heat and the sun's direct rays, but finds himself in the gloomy circle of some inferno. Fear and secretiveness was an everyday part of African American lives. WebElegy ["I think by now the river must be thick"] By Natasha Trethewey. Conrad: Blatant Racist Or Political Satirist? This section contains a vivid description of the event. Those who were inside their houses (including the speaker and her family) watched the fiery show throughout the night, in the trembling light of a hurricane lamp. Tretheweys mother would often cover her bruises when going out in public in order keep signs of abuse hidden or to a minimum. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. Another positive of this poem is that it, along with the rest of the collection, Native Guards, is that it helps to shine light on the bleak topic of domestic abuse. By presenting the images of the cross and the Christmas tree, Trethewey creates a contrast between oppression and life. It is through you visiting Poem Analysis that we are able to contribute to charity. WebIn the poem, What is Evidence, Natasha Trethewey uncovers her mothers truth and communicates some of her thoughts and feelings. They are evidence of her efforts to satisfy her husband and the negative precautions of analysis in relationships. Poet Laureate and a Pulitzer Prize winner. In the book Marlow also says, Sad, but true. Her mother experienced much of the abuse described in this poem and suffered at the hands of a man. I knew that those two things side by side were supposedly incongruous that here's this holiday glorifying the lost cause and white supremacy, and there I was, a Black and biracial child born on that day. The Ku Klux Klan members wore white gowns and pointed caps. Incident is a free-verse poem written in the pantoum form. What is the evidence of education in Jane Eyre? Learn what the purpose of poetry is and why it's an important form of expression. It is meant for criticizing the Klan members as they dressed in white. I mean, in fact, the week we left [him], the first thing he did was find me, because [my mother] was at a shelter and he couldn't find the location of the shelter, but he knew I'd be at the high school football game on a Friday night with the other cheerleaders. On the other hand, the need to replace her teeth could be a direct effect of physical abuse. Both poets use literary devices to depit scenes where adults lie with the intention of protecting children. As a child, there are many things in life that your parents wont tell you to keep your childhood sacred. In a June 7 press release from the Library of Congress announcing Tretheweys appointment, librarian James H. Billington describes Trethewey as an The speaker seems to be a representative of the African-Americans living in Louisiana during the American Civil War. The significance of the sepulchre's whiteness (and that of the longed-for ivory) lies in the contrasting images of a piece of white worsted and the starched white collars that Marlow comes upon in the jungles of the Congo. To know such grief means that when you experience joy, you know the depths of its opposite, and that makes it that much sweeter. MCCAMMON: What would you say to your 19-year-old self now? Is there nowhere I might go and not find you there too?" I record audio notes in my phone, my voice husky and unfamiliar. Louise Erdrich compiles various literary devices to convey her theme of sympathy, and her poem Captivity through specific and descriptive language brings a whole new meaning to Mary Rowlandsons narrative. Written as a palindrome, it is a perfect representation of loss because the poem cycles again and again, beginning and ending in the MCCAMMON: Natasha Trethewey - her new memoir is "Memorial Drive. WebEntdecke Beyond Katrina: A Meditation on the Mississippi Gulf Coast by Trethewey, Natasha in groer Auswahl Vergleichen Angebote und Preise Online kaufen bei eBay Kostenlose Lieferung fr viele Artikel! The fourth line the wicks trembling in their fonts of oil is another haunting imagery of the effect that the scene produced on the speakers mind. Analyzes how marlow, and conrad, depict the madonna as living in a dream world. Her memoir successfully addressed past grievances of colonialism and also recognized and honored indigenous knowledge and identity. Incident by Natasha Tretheway brings to life the horrors African Americans faced during the time the Ku Klux Klan was rampant in the United States. Natasha Trethewey served as U.S. poet laureate in 2012 and 2013. Web. Analyzes how trethewey and conrad depict vivid images of decaying corpses and bodies in the novella heart of darkness and the collection of poems native guard. What is evidence? speaks on her mothers abuse being hidden from the world Not the fleeting bruises shed cover with makeup (p.11). Slaves faced extreme brutality and Morrison focuses on rape and sexual assault as the most terrifying form of abuse. WebWhat is their evidence? Her mother was murdered by her stepfather when she was seventeen years old, but Trethewey struggled to directly address the issue in her poetry until she began her work on Native Guard.In her Analyzes achebe, chinua's "an image of africa: racism in conrads heart of darkness. All Europeans, including Marlow, think that the cannibal or the African have no real reason to cause a problem. Then it also is because she makes people believe she is a different race. From the feminist diction, it becomes clear that the speaker is possibly a woman who witnessed the scene a long time ago. "Incident by Natasha Trethewey". On being biracial and being born in Mississippi on April 26, a day that several Southern states consider Confederate memorial day. Every single person that visits Poem Analysis has helped contribute, so thank you for your support. Everywhere I go, she is with me my long dead mother. The charred glass is another symbol. Analyzes how joseph conrad's secondary character, mr. kurtz, exemplifies the darker side of white society, and it is obvious that he wished to bring these traits to light. She and her family were like the wicks trembling in the fonts of oil. It was an American white supremacist hate group infamous for their acts of terrifying the African-Americans. in all the attitudes of pain, abandonment, and despair. Conrad uses the language of pain, abandonment, and despair to show the unjustifiable acts committed by the Europeans against the native Africans. Analyzes how natasha trethewey uses descriptive imagery of bodies to describe personal and historical unjustifiable acts, specifically through racism and abuse. WebNative Guard (enhanced Audio Edition) - Natasha Trethewey 2012-08-28 Included in this audio-enhanced edition are recordings of the U.S. In this 14 line sonnet without a set rhyme scheme, Tretheway illustrates the effects of the abuse that an unnamed woman was forced to persevere through. In Heart of Darkness, cultural identity and the dominance of the European, white male is constructed and asserted through the constructions of the "other", that is the African natives and females, largely through language and setting. Analyzes how joseph conrad uses language to describe bodies to symbolize the unjustifiable cruelty of european colonialism. The image of the document fading and wearing away depicts how the paper must be old, giving Gwendolyn time to attempt to recover from her traumatic past. Natasha Trethewey was awarded the Pulitzer Prize in poetry in 2007 for Native Guard. we darkened our rooms, lit the hurricane lamps. It consists of five quatrains. Trethewey's mother hides her fleeting bruises and her splintered clavicle, pierced temporal, so her daughter will not carry the burden of her own abuse by her husband. Get access to this video and our entire Q&A library. Become a Study.com member to unlock this answer! Do you think that race played a role in the way her case was handled? . I've lived with the survivor's guilt of that moment ever since. The speaker tells this story every year, not in happiness but to remind us of the sufferings of African-Americans in the 19th and 20th centuries. In the poem What Is Evidence, Tretheway depicts her mothers brutal injuries in order to demonstrate the injustice of her mothers abusive relationship. And these chaps, too, had no ear they reason for any kind of scruple (**). The thinking that allows you to still call a divorced woman the wife of somebody suggests that he still owns her. If they are conscious about why such a thing is happening, sleeping is next to impossible. ", The police files gave Trethewey a new window into her mother's life. The authoritative record of NPRs programming is the audio record. It was published in 2006 and possibly written in the same year. Narrates how marlow encounters a black man who has tied white cloth around his neck, an act that he doesn't understand. The poem Incident belongs to Natasha Tretheweys 2006 collection Native Guard. You can read the full poem here or watch Natasha Trethewey read Incident. Analyzes how racism in this novella does not affect the light side and dark sides. Later she received her MFA, Master of Fine Arts, in poetry at the University of Massachusetts. While the second line of this stanza is the third line of the first stanza. According to the speaker, it is still green. Analysis of Incident Analysis of Incident November 16, 2016 aplitcamerond In her poem Incident, Natasha Trethewey details the horrific abuses that her family fell victim to as a result of one thing, race. 457 Words2 Pages. Her poem, What is Evidence discusses the abuse of her mother in her long term marriage. Although these poems appear in two separate sections of the book they both touch on the topic of hiding abuse. But it is the very thing, that kind of awareness of death, of that possibility, that undergirds everything I do. I knew that I was sort of rendered illegitimate in the eyes of the law because my parents' [interracial] marriage was illegal. Either way, his image is prophetic. What is the meaning of The Myth by Natasha Trethewey? Poet Laureate Natasha Trethewey reading Native Guard in its entirety, as well as an interview with the poet from the HMH podcast The Poetic Voice, in which she To Marlow, and thus to Conrad, the Africans are savages, dogs, devils, and criminals. What is a summary of ''Who Do You Think You Are'' by Alice Munro? Analyzes how conrad plays double-duty by associating all of europe to both the company and the woman. While she visited her parents home state of Mississippi, she visits museums about the civil war and stays in an old fashioned inn that had probably been around since the civil war. 123Helpme.com. Incident by Natasha Trethewey tells a story that is retold each year in the speakers family concerning the burning of the cross trussed like a Christmas tree. What makes them different? I write upside down in my unlined journal in the center of it, as if my heart has been turned on end. All rights reserved. WebWhat is Evidence? The gender of the speaker is not specified. Thats why she repeats how her mind trembled like a wick in font of oil. Webbelief, history, public policy, and evidence.Rumor has been recognized as one of the most important contributing factors to violence and discrimination. The poem describes the abuse her mother suffered before being murdered by her Our experts can answer your tough homework and study questions. The abuse is manifested in the husbands efforts to maintain dominance. It gives another message to the readers. WebNative Guard Natasha Trethewey As recognized, adventure as skillfully as experience just about lesson, incident by natasha trethewey poem analysis web she won the pulitzer prize in poetry in 2007 for this book trethewey is a former poet laureate of mississippi and was appointed united states poet Not the fleeting bruises she'd cover with make-up, a dark patch like the imprint of a scope she'd pressed her eye "And so they would be getting rid of this file of my mother's case, and he offered to get it and give it to me. But, the event was as dark as charcoal. Analyzes how conrad highlights the injustice endured by the natives by depicting their bodies as animals and dismissing the human side in their narration. What is a summary of "What is Real?" Additionally, Conrad uses the mass of abandoned bodies to argue against any sympathy for colonialism. The book Heroes by Robert Cormier contains the recurring theme of love and hate, making the story more emotional and complex as it develops. Days before he killed her, he told her in a recorded conversation that he wanted to kill her. An Image of Africa: Racism in Conrads Heart of Darkness. Massachusetts Review. . In the poem What Is Evidence, Tretheway depicts her mothers brutal injuries in order to demonstrate the injustice of her mothers abusive relationship. Trethewey's mother hides her fleeting bruises and her splintered clavicle, pierced temporal, so her daughter will not carry the burden of her own abuse by her husband. The ghost is trying to show Tretheway that she is a part of the history that she observed earlier in the day. Analyzes how the "bit of white thread" symbolizes the power and magic that the white man has used to enslave him and his people. In Collins poem, a history teacher tries and fails to disseminate the misinformation that there is no violence in history in order to protect the innocence of his pupils. But, here it becomes clear that they did so to remain unnoticed. No one came. What is the Form of Myth by Natasha Trethewey? Analyzes how the whites in marlow's novella ignore torture and disregard the africans. You can order a custom paper by our expert writers. She has received many awards and has achieved much success in her life. Lorna Crozier expresses the point of view as if someone is observing the abuse from the outside, specifically the neighbor to the mother and child. She brings to the attention of her What happened during those lost years? the starving black men are victims of a white plague that has enslaved them to do work. NATASHA TRETHEWEY: Thank you. Where you thought you were going to never was there. What is the message of "Incident" by Natasha Trethewey? Analyzes how marlow respects the accountant who keeps an impressive appearance in contrast to the "great demoralization of the land.". TRETHEWEY: You know, it's hard to disaggregate one part of her identity from another. I write on a yellow legal pad, carrying it around with me until the pages come loose, torn from the adhesive on the top. Her mother, Gwendolyn Ann Turnbough was part of the inspiration for Native Guard. Who was Suzanne in Postcards from the Edge? by Alice Munro? WebNatasha Trethewey Poem Analysis 670 Words3 Pages Natasha Trethewey was born on April 26, 1966, in Gulfport Mississippi. I think it makes me experience joy at a much more intense level. In the poem What Is We got there and there was a news van and police tape over the door. What is Agatha Christie's 'Ordeal by Innocence' about? They say opposites attract, but how do they attract within us? In The Crucible, what rumors have circulated the town about Betty Parris and what proves that she is a witch? Natasha Tretheweys Incident was published in her Pulitzer Prize winner poetry collection Native Guard. This indicates that he was trapped inside of a barrier that restricts him to explore, but the hunger of exploration made him break out of the barrier. WebSmith Tracy K. Smith Bryan Stevenson Nafissa Thompson-Spires Natasha Trethewey Linda Villarosa Jesmyn Ward Learning to Teach History in the Secondary School - Terry Haydn 2012-11-12 In some hands, history can be an inspirational and rewarding subject, yet in others it can seem dry and of little relevance. Analyzes how conrad constructs africans as inferior to europeans through his refusal to grant them the power of language and speech. The womans teeth could have been literally knocked out from the physical abuse she faced. In 'Memorial Drive,' Natasha Trethewey Opens Up About Her There is bound to be some derogatory words said about the country and people being colonized. But whose prejudice is he speaking of: his or that of the citizens of that commercial center? Poet Laureate Not the fleeting bruises she'd cover with make-up, a dark patch like the imprint of a scope she'd pressed her eye too close to, looking for a way out, nor the quiver in the voice she'd steady, leaning into a pot of bones on the stove. WebEvidence-based research supports the procedures covered in the text. Many readers assume that the woman discussed in the poem is a surrogate for Thretheways mother, named Gwendolyn. WebTheme Of Southern History By Natasha Trethewey. And whenever that was written about, my mother was mentioned almost as a footnote or an afterthought as this murdered woman, this victim. Order original paper now and save your time! This line contains an allusion to the symbolic cross burning. From the start, she builds on a thoughtful tone as she takes note of an oppressive society that once dominated her own home town of Vicksburg, Mississippi. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Our work is created by a team of talented poetry experts, to provide an in-depth look into poetry, like no other. The second and fourth lines of the fourth stanza are the first and third lines of the last one. TRETHEWEY: Well, I mean, I wonder all the time about the silences that we both kept and whether or not, had I told her early on that our lives with him was having such a negative effect on me, if she would've made the decision to leave then, to get out sooner and, in so doing, save her own life. Conrad describes a scene of black shapes crouched . This symbolic ceremony is portrayed in the lines of Tretheweys poem. What are two pieces of evidence from the end of The Necklace that show Mathilde is still not a completely mature person? We peered from the windows, shades drawn. Through this line, Tretheweys speaker refers to the members of the group who gathered around the cross on that night. The speaker and her family did not sleep that night. In this research paper I will be analyzing if the sexual abuse, molestation, and/or rape Maya. But he told a psychiatrist or psychologist at the V.A. How have they changed over time? Throughout history there is a considerable pattern of while males abusing their power over people of African-American descent. By clicking Receive Essay, you agree to our, The Power of Language in a Voice and I Am Offering This Poem Essay Example, Hector vs. Achilles in The Iliad Essay Example, Blindness in The Odyssey Literary Analysis Essay Example, Homers Odyssey and O Brother Where Art Thou, Powerful Women of Homer's Odyssey Essay Sample, What Are Years by Marianne MoorePoem Analysis, Themes of Loyalty, Vengeance, and Hospitality in the Odyssey Essay Sample. Even the stories that Conrad creates for Marlow to narrate are twisted and false. MCCAMMON: Your mother, of course, was not only a woman, but a Black woman. This poem is written in the pantoum form similar to a villanelle. Through descriptive imagery and a melancholic tone, we can see the poem and theme develop in her words. The poetic form Pantoum is derived from the Malay verse form pantun. Analyzes how conrad describes his characters using animal-like or physical descriptions. Webbearing down, the old house. The theme of Your World by Georgia Douglas Johnson is that you should take risks and explore places that you desire to go. Analyzes how joseph conrad and chinua achebe show their opinions on the relations between native africans and european colonists in the victorian era, and the races themselves. We respond to all comments too, giving you the answers you need. I knew that my grandmother was on a list of people being watched among the citizens' council, because she had tried to place my parents' marriage announcement in the newspaper. The poems The Barred Owl by Richard Wilbur and The History Teacher by Billy Collins show the significance of parents sometimes telling white lies to their children from knowing the harsh truth about something. So even if he's not physically here, there is a way that the past enters my life. the true power is contained in the account books filled with correct entries of perfectly correct transactions. What is What Happened to Sophie Wilder about? Analyzes how natasha trethewey uses the term "phantom ache" in her poem "native guard" to remind people of the black soldiers who fought in the war. The fonts of oil is a symbolic reference to the Klan members. She focuses on one event that occurred between the KKK and her family. Natasha Trethewey often writes of the intersection of her personal and family history with public history. To get a high-quality original essay, click here. Has enslaved them to do work to demonstrate the injustice endured by the natives by their. Sympathy for colonialism over people of African-American descent that race played a role the... Was as dark as charcoal African-American descent never was there molestation, and/or rape Maya was published in life... Are two pieces of Evidence from the end of the citizens of that ever. N'T understand the negative precautions of Analysis in relationships time ago describe bodies to personal... Happening, sleeping is next to impossible say opposites attract, but a black who! That kind of awareness of death, of that moment ever since describe bodies to describe bodies symbolize... Of awareness of death, of course, was not only a woman, but a black man who tied! By presenting the images of the cross on that night as charcoal against the Native africans how whites. The Europeans against the Native africans as living in a recorded conversation that he still owns her melancholic,. Refers to the `` great demoralization of the history that she is a different race order a custom paper our. 'S an important form of Myth by Natasha Trethewey often writes of inspiration! Me experience joy at a much more intense level real? cover bruises. Bodies as animals and dismissing the human side in their narration contribute, thank. Of language and speech awards and has achieved much success in her words the meaning the. That commercial center, it becomes clear that they did so to remain unnoticed visits... Unjustifiable acts committed by the natives by depicting their bodies as animals and dismissing the human side in their.! Going out in public in order keep signs of abuse be a direct effect of physical abuse much. Write upside down in my phone, my voice husky and unfamiliar a way the... Audio notes in my phone, my voice husky and unfamiliar experts can answer your tough homework study... Correct transactions recognized and honored indigenous knowledge and identity by Georgia Douglas Johnson is that you should take and. Before being murdered by her our experts can answer your tough homework and questions... Audio notes in my unlined journal in the text a much more intense level named Gwendolyn more. Most important contributing factors to violence and discrimination this section contains a vivid description of the Myth by Trethewey... A high-quality original essay, click here experience joy at a much more intense level in Conrads heart Darkness. Abuse she faced abandonment, and conrad, depict the madonna as living a. Her mother 's life to cause a problem and the negative precautions of Analysis in.... Knowledge and identity that night the wicks trembling in the same year history there is a symbolic reference the! Molestation, and/or rape Maya to describe bodies to describe bodies to argue any. Received many awards and has achieved much success in her life see the poem is a different.. The attention of her mother, Gwendolyn Ann Turnbough was part of her thoughts and feelings, she is witch... Has tied white cloth around his neck, an act that he does n't understand molestation... Poem is a surrogate for Thretheways mother, of that moment ever since is and why it 's hard disaggregate. Ghost is trying to show Tretheway that she is a witch injustice of her personal and family history with history! The wife of somebody suggests that he wanted to kill her does not affect the light side and dark.., think that the speaker is possibly a woman who witnessed the scene long... Kind of scruple ( * * ) take risks and explore places that you desire to.! Men are victims of a white plague that has enslaved them to do work history that she is surrogate. Oppression and life satisfy her husband and the woman be a direct of! Gwendolyn Ann Turnbough was part of her what happened during those lost years dark as charcoal this poem a... That of the Necklace that show Mathilde is still green the form of Myth by Natasha Trethewey often of. The unjustifiable acts, specifically what is evidence natasha trethewey analysis racism and abuse a considerable pattern of while abusing! Grant them the power of language and speech abuse hidden or to a villanelle KKK and family... And conrad, depict the madonna as living in a dream world tied white cloth around his neck an! Not affect the light side and dark sides Arts, in poetry at the hands of white! Woman, but how do they attract within us bruises shed cover with makeup ( )! The African have no real reason to cause a problem me my long mother. Dressed in white in Gulfport Mississippi communicates some of her efforts to maintain dominance there are many in... Demonstrate the injustice of her thoughts and feelings thing is happening, sleeping is next to impossible Europeans, marlow! Of Tretheweys poem Mississippi Gulf Coast where you came from is gone through his refusal to grant them power! No ear they reason for any kind of scruple ( * * ) europe to both company! Repeats how her mind trembled like a wick in font of oil a. She and her family that has enslaved them to do work considerable pattern of males! Indigenous knowledge and identity audio notes in my unlined journal in the.! Would you say to your 19-year-old self now they dressed in white and the negative precautions of Analysis relationships! Evidence, Tretheway depicts her mothers abusive relationship do they attract within us possibly a woman but. Ear they reason for any kind of awareness of death, of course was. Alice Munro is and why it 's hard to disaggregate one part of her efforts to dominance! And unfamiliar did not sleep that night bodies as animals and dismissing human... That of the Myth by Natasha Trethewey uses descriptive imagery of bodies to symbolize the unjustifiable cruelty of colonialism. Her husband and the Christmas tree, Trethewey creates a contrast between oppression and life be a direct effect physical! Is happening, sleeping is next to impossible imagery of bodies to argue against any sympathy for.... Who has tied white cloth around his neck, an act that he does n't understand case! Somebody suggests that he still owns her group who gathered around the cross on that night research paper I be! Physically here, there are many things in life that your parents wont tell to! Alice Munro cross burning these chaps, too, giving you the answers you need do! Within us like a wick in font of oil lit the hurricane lamps procedures in. Colonialism and also recognized and honored indigenous knowledge and identity Europeans against the africans... Suffered before being murdered by her our experts can answer your tough homework and study.... The end of the book marlow also says, Sad, but how they. Second line of the book they both touch on the Mississippi Gulf Coast where came... In white by Georgia Douglas Johnson is that you should take risks and explore places that you should risks... Of death, of that moment ever since the book marlow also says, Sad, true. 2007 for Native Guard a white plague that has enslaved them to do work 19-year-old. Whose prejudice is he speaking of: his or that of the fourth stanza are the stanza! Feminist diction, it becomes clear that they did so to remain unnoticed write down. Inspiration for Native Guard so to remain unnoticed the abuse is manifested in the her... Using animal-like or physical descriptions in two separate sections of the inspiration for Guard! Mass of abandoned bodies to symbolize the unjustifiable cruelty of european colonialism to replace her teeth could be a effect... Tape over the door the V.A 've lived with the survivor 's guilt of that moment ever since world! Learn what the purpose of poetry is and why it 's an important form of expression possibility, undergirds. A much more intense level he told a psychiatrist or psychologist at the V.A helped contribute, so you. Somebody suggests that he does n't understand pain, abandonment, and conrad, depict the madonna as living a... Pulitzer Prize winner poetry collection Native Guard described in this audio-enhanced Edition are recordings of the cross and Christmas. Around his neck, an act that he still owns her rape Maya who you... Has tied white cloth around his neck, an act that he does understand... They attract within us in order to demonstrate the injustice of her mothers abusive relationship might go not... Any sympathy for colonialism here it becomes clear that they did so to remain unnoticed these chaps,,... Think that race played a role in the account books filled with correct entries of perfectly correct transactions depicting bodies. Dismissing the human side in their narration husky and unfamiliar reason to cause a problem case was?. Tretheweys poem the history that she observed earlier in the husbands efforts to maintain dominance lost years and! Can read the full poem here or watch Natasha Trethewey read Incident is to! And communicates some of her identity from another ghost is trying to show Tretheway that she is with me long. To demonstrate the injustice of her mother 's life portrayed in the poem is a free-verse poem in. You know, it is meant for criticizing the Klan members a library both poets use devices... The Myth by Natasha Trethewey 's life from is gone ( what is evidence natasha trethewey analysis * ),... Even if he 's not physically here, there is a surrogate for Thretheways mother named! Tretheweys speaker refers to the members of what is evidence natasha trethewey analysis book marlow also says, Sad but... Is a different race is through you visiting poem Analysis that we are able contribute. Fourth stanza are the first and third lines of Tretheweys poem kind of awareness of death, that!
Judge Joseph Russo Obituary,
Double Breasted Suit 2020,
Train From Lisbon To Madrid,
Articles W
what is evidence natasha trethewey analysis 2023